A British doctor who used to work at Shifa Hospital, Gaza’s largest medical center, under which the IDF says Hamas operates a major command and control base, has confirmed that there were areas of the hospital where he could not go, or else he would be shot.
In a recent interview with the English-language channel of French broadcaster France24…
They blasted a hole through a garage floor to find a tunnel, that’s not a terror command center and not something a member of the hospital would stumble upon. If this was a big important storage and command site that random doctors would wander into, the troops there would have found it already by just opening doors.
These situations can still be reconciled. Perhaps this particular doctor had a habit of blasting holes in floors and had to be told not to do that under threat of being shot.
Most probable scenario.
Medic by trade, demo man by hobby.
deleted by creator
The attack was planned for over a year. Covering a door with a wall 3 weeks in advance is easy.
I doubt Israel has trouble sensing voids through a wall, or even just mapping out missing space the old fashioned way.
And their very failure to defend against this attack is exactly why you should be suspicious of their claims to intelligence justifying attacking hospitals. Their intelligence services very clearly aren’t as good as they’ve been claiming.
I assume this is what they are doing, but we don’t know. It is an active war zone. The new walls or the passages behind them may be trapped.
If they won’t provide evidence in a few weeks it will be a different story. In the meanwhile they did provide evidence for the existence of tunnels under Shifa. They also released another video from inside the tunnel that the guardian don’t show.
Parts of their intelligence collecting bodies did warn of the attack. The warnings were ignored, there isn’t a clear picture why, not a public one.
The war is a month old and 10,000 people are dead. They’ve already moved on to another hospital. In a few weeks there won’t be any hospitals left in Gaza and they’ll be telling us the real command center is under their next target. They’ve done nothing to earn this trust and done multiple things that invite heavy skepticism.
It doesn’t matter how old the war is, it matters how much time IDF had in Shifa hospital.
Where they already shown underground tunnels. They already shown the area to have military usage (making it into a valid target).
Now they need to show access from the hospital to the tunnels.
BTW, this is nothing new, Hamas has been using Shifa since atleast 2014. I think no one will claim Amnesty is biased towards Israel.
You’re asking for “a few weeks” before anyone decides whether invading hospitals is a good idea. It very much matters how much damage will be done in that time period. 5 days is a lot of time. They have control, technology, manpower, and a pressing need to justify this attack.
And they don’t seem to be in any hurry, because they know that, like a police shooting, if they can just delay long enough (say “a few weeks”), attention will move on to a whole new horror. They just need to keep the outrage at manageable levels to squeeze a few more weeks of destruction out of the conflict so they can then advocate that all these pesky people should just move elsewhere for “humanitarian reasons”. No one should be starting from a place of trust about all this destruction when members of the far right government are actively supporting ethnic cleansing.
And fuck your antiseptic deflection about valid targets. It’s not justified to kill five times as many civilians as enemy fighters. It’s not justified to tell people to evacuate south and then bomb where they evacuate to. And it’s not justified to invade a hospital for what appears to be a handful of weapons. This is callous apologia for crimes against humanity.
I think the Israeli government doesn’t give a flying fuck about your rage. If all you want to do is rage, go ahead, it will only impact you and the people close to you in a negative way.
Action to reduce the chance of further violence in the region will will be measured in years of work. If you can’t wait a few weeks to get more information you lack the emotional fortitude required for years of work.
You said correctly that part of the Israeli government is a bunch of right wing nut jobs that want to exterminate the Palestinans. You failed to mention they are not part of small war cabinet, and they are pissed about it.
What I’m looking at is the time it took Israel to get to the tunnel they got to, and breach the blast door.. It means they are taking the time to be carful, both on their soldiers and, as much as possible Palestinan civilians.
As for your rage about my claim that they are carful about Palatinatan civilian with so many dead. The war created between 100k to 200k Israelis refugees, placed many millions under constant rockets attack and costs Israel over one billion shekel per day. This is a lose Israel didn’t have to take, they have the weaponry to wipe out Gaza in 24-48 hours. They could have killed every last Palestinan cheaply and quickly without the harm to Israeli population and economy. They lost between 300 to 400 IDF soldiers already. They keep losing soldiers in Gaza. Just because they didn’t want to wipe out Gaza (the right wing nut jobs want that, but they don’t get to vote on that).
Is what happening currently in Gaza horrible? Yes, it gives me nightmares. Is Israel going into the hospitals a war crime? No, the second Hamas used them for military purposes they lost their protection.
Most of all, it makes me sad to see the progressive left tie it self with Hamas (WTF). Replying from from rage and calling to the extermination of Israel (not very progressive) with false claims about the war in Gaza. With zero understanding of the reality of war.
You are missing the plot, israel’s war crimes are happening in the West Bank. The right wing nut jobs live and develop their hate over there. Israel can stop them by treating the West Bank settlers as terrorist (they are). But that not going to happen.
Do you want to stop that? Go for the money and freedom of movement of settelers in the West Bank. They are sponsored using private money of crazy Christian Evangelists, mostly from the USA. They want the settlements to spread so it will to create conflict that bring Gog and Magog.
Do you want to prevent further bloodshed in the area? You will also need to stop money flow to Hamas and other radical Islamist groups in the area. They will stat wars with Israel no matter how Israel treat the Palatinans.
tl;dr: war is ugly, brutal and horrifying. If you want change, you need to economically strav religious nut jobs from both sides. Enough of the money is ‘outside influence’ that it may be done.
Don’t push it off on the Israeli government. I’m not talking to them and you’re not a neutral third party just making observations. I’m talking to you and your shitty justifications for mass murder. You are an active participant.
How on earth do you believe this? This is your brain on decades of nationalistic propaganda.
You want a pat on the back for not just nuking it? Even Israel’s rightwing regime knows there are limits before even the US has had too much. So they go slow and steady, destroying infrastructure and houses and then says “look how hard it is to stay in Gaza, you should just leave”. Not doing maximal war crimes isn’t praiseworthy.
No one is rooting for fucking Hamas. This is a straw man to make you feel like the people calling you out are ignorant or immoral so you don’t need to address it. And I understand the reality of war and the culpability of the individual citizens. When my country was beating the war drums and then committing crimes against humanity, I protested, not made excuses for it.