It’s like humans just know, deep down, that working to make profits is so unnecessary… and yet, 130 years of capitalism poisoning our minds.
1 in 5 executive leaders agree.
It’s not even majority, why even report it?
Because one executives opinion is worth 100,000,000 proletariat opinions. Hence capitalism.
Even if that were true, it’s 1 in 5 executives, so 4 in 5 say the oposite. Which why I said, why even report it?
“Just vote with your wallet,” they’ll say.
no one wants to work anymore
– person that’s never had to work before
Not to undermine but plenty of people do actually like the work they do, that doesn’t change that they deserve to be paid for agreeing to do that work for you specifically.
A major issue is that a lot of jobs people do out of passion for the work are underpaid, if not outright looked down on, in contemporary society. Teachers, caretakers, artists and many other classes of professionals are exploited to work for severely suppressed wages due to their passion for what they do.
Yup, just my random tangential anecdote here, but I consider myself very lucky to have a decently paid job that allows me to work from home. I started fostering kittens a few years ago and have found myself quite passionate about it. The problem is that it takes lots of time and a good bit of money and is unpaid. The organization I volunteer for covers medical expenses, but everything else is coming out of my own pocket. I guess they technically offer to cover food, but it’s a lot of hassle (and frequent upset tummies and/or cats refusing to eat) to actually utilize their food supplies.
People have suggested that I get a job at the shelter or as a vet, so I could get paid to work with animals, but the work is totally different, likely pays less than my current job, and the in person nature of those jobs would severely limit my ability to continue fostering.
Thank you for fostering, that’s hard work. For what it’s worth the only people making good money in veterinary medicine are management and the veterinarians (and that can vary). Vet techs, assistants, receptionists, and kennel techs generally all make shit.
Hell, if you’re improving the world even well paying jobs pay shit unless it’s completely unglamorous
deleted by creator
“Being a teacher is not a profession, but a passion.” Heard that BS multiple times.
Also getting shocked looks when I answer “because of the good pay” when asked why I am a teacher. (Disclaimer, am not american)
I love learning about programmation, and it is definitely one of my passion. I still get paid a buttload more than teachers. The argument is fucking bullshit.
That is one factor, but there is another factor and I can tell you this as someone not working- it’s really boring having very little to do on a day-to-day basis.
Not that I’d ever work without being paid and I would much rather do WFH because I don’t really give a shit about the social aspect, but giving me shit to do every day would at least keep my mind occupied.
Tbh there are people who are never bored, because they have a strong intrinsic motivation to try new things or improve. Usually in things that arent jobs, like hobbies or volunteer work/clubs.
For example I would love to improve my programming, switch to linux, set up home server, learn how to lockpick, go climbing or pick up bodybuilding and build cardio, redecorate my home, maybe dive into streaming game-speedruns…
And when you were done with doing all of those things?
There are always more things. Once learning how to setup a server, there come more servers to learn about. After learning to program in one language, there come other languages and interesting programming projects etc. And along the way, you’ll hear about and discover other interesting hobbies to check out. Maybe learning how to lockpick and learning how to program combine to learning about hacking, or cyber security. It goes in and on. There are always more interesting things to learn if you’re curious.
I also am an endlessly curious person haha!
Well maybe you never get bored, but I certainly do. And I’m far from alone there. Sure, there are always more interesting things to learn if you’re curious. There’s also only so much energy you can put into them. And if you devote a lot of your energy to one of them, it’s basically an unpaid job. Which is fine if that’s what makes you happy, but it’s still a job.
Boredom is good for someone. The brain hates it so it forces itself to be creative or do something. You have more energy if so much of it wasn’t dedicated to trying to work and suckle off of capitalism teat so you can survive. That is the thing when so much energy is focused on work you miss community/hobby work that is a healthier thing to build for one’s self for one’s overall happiness. If it costs less to live the more you can spend on hobbies which allows more hobbies to be livable jobs in your community
I always get bored! That’s what drives me to explore and learn.
Boredom sparks new interests. You need to experience it to understand.
I’m suffering from a long-term serious illness where I’m not working. I think I’ve experienced boredom.
Yeah I like my job but I sure as fuck don’t like to enrich someone with it without receiving a fair compensation.
True, but if I didn’t have to work I’d be an engineer elsewhere. I’d work on community and personal projects
Nobody wants to work at the minimum wage anymore!
And no one wants to raise the minimum wage either so we are stuck in a stalemate situation
I mean, there are politicians that have worked to increase it it’s just that crooked politicians manage to get jobs that block it from happening.
The development of the Protestant Work Ethic was a disaster for the human race
Nobody wants to (pay me for my) work anymore.
I just need to figure out a way to monetize sleeping and I’ll be set for life.
Start a twitch stream. The sleep stream fad has passed but I’m sure there’s still an audience who will pay to wake you up with bass boosted memes.
There’s that Japanese guy that filmed his whole life on a Livestream or whatever.
Mattress QA
Twitch, OnlyFans Cams, another cam site.
Gotta sell what you’ve got and sexualize it to high hell.
Gotta… Sexualize it to high hell
So sleep naked and stream it. Gotchu.
Or in very tight clothing. Mystery sells. Mix in some ASMR and wham bam thank you ma’am.
I know you’re being sarcastic, but would there be something that fulfilled your heart that might remotely be monetizable?
I used to monitor systems remotely from my home. On night shift I had an alarm going every 12 minutes to check the screens and emails. Shitty sleep, but slightly better than no sleep.
You could script this, likely. If something bad, sound alarm.
Nobody wanted to work for someone else
FTFY
The problem with being self employed is you don’t have one boss, you have hundreds of bosses.
Only if you have hundreds of customers. No customers, no bosses.
You have an intriguing business plan.
Not if you’re just growing your own food.
Fuck that noise. I fire my “bosses” all the time.
So do I. It doesn’t do away with working to other people’s standards though.
Bosses aren’t really a problem until they form a monopoly or collude into a cartel.
A multitude of independent bosses is always going to be superior to a single boss.
I don’t disagree. I worked for an asshole for 20 years and am now self employed, and it’s vastly superior being on your own. But it’s like the difference between throwing and catching one ball versus juggling 5 balls. And sometimes a chainsaw gets thrown in.
I do want to work, just not on the stuff companies want to pay me for. I want to work on the stuff companies expect for free (open source code).
Well said.
If nobody wants to work then who the hell are all these people on the freeway during rush hour?
People getting paid enough to want to work.
Most people want to work. They just can’t afford to.
deleted by creator
How does this explain early societies and people that opted to work to improve their environment before money was invented?
I disagree. We do just want to work. That’s what makes us human. We labor.
Working for our own benefit or for the benefit of those we love is a natural inclination. Working for others, often harder and at a detriment to our own personal joy, without a comparable benefit to us and our family is not natural.
Not to mention to our physical detriment, sometimes acutely, always long-term.
Agreed. Thats why I never made the claim that people have a natural urge to get yelled at by a shitty manager in an exploitative fast food gig. No one is saying that here.
The situation you describe is an illustration of alienation in the workplace, and this happens when workers lose the means of production. All of the comments in this thread tiptoe around this idea - for which there have been volumes of thought written btw.
My issue with the meme is that it is ahistorical and can distract people away from the concept of alienation. The capitalist class pays us not because we are “naturally opposed to working” (which is the thesis of the meme), but because it is unbearable to work in an alienating environment, which, as you perfectly explained, abstracts us away from the products we create, compartmentalizes our work, and violently separated us from working for our families or communities.
I think your point makes sense if the meme defines “work” as broadly as you do: “any labor.”. However, i read the meme to refer to “work for others.”. So i think your criticism of it is on shaky ground because that criticism assumes and requires the existence of an intent that was not present.
Work has a broad reach. Putting effort into something is work, be it something you enjoy, like building a chair or a table for example, or into a company project.
Sure, but in the context of the meme, “work” means “doing labor for someone else in exchange for payment”. Broadening the scope of the word “work” is valid, sure, but bound to cause confusion given the context.
People worked to have a calorie surplus so they could not work the next day, or they could make sure their shelter wasn’t leaking, or they could do something they found entertaining.
People don’t work for the sake of work.
So you’re saying people labor in order to entertain, love, create, do art, and do philosophy?
Sounds very human to me.
Never did i claim that people “work for the sake of work”. My argument is that humans can be characterized as working creatures who use labor to change their environment - be it geographically, politically, socially, etc…
And that is very true.
It’s that at some point someone realized they could use their momentary surplus to exploit someone else’s dire need and thus use other people’s labor to generate an even larger surplus for themselves.
The rationale to justify this exploitation has changed through the ages, as well as how much has to be spent to coax others - going from slavery all the way to whatever is on the other end, which I guess would be the shared ownership of the means of production.
Getting me to improve my own house or community isn’t hard.
Getting me to improve your house that I’m not allowed to use? Yeah, you’re gonna have to pay me.
I think people like to work when the work/coworkers are actually enjoyable or the work goes towards a goal one wants to achieve
If you didn’t work you died of starvation.
The majority of all people who ever lived were in subsistence agriculture, which needed constant labour to produce the food you needed to eat in order to keep yourself and your family alive. What improvements were made were developed to keep starvation at bay. If you gave a medieval peasant modern farming equipment, they’d be jazzed about how little time they’d have to spend plowing and milling and threshing and harvesting and how much more time they could spend getting piss drunk with their family and friends.
A babylonian farmer didn’t “just want to work.” They wanted to live, and that meant they spent their life in back-breaking labour in the fields.
The majority of all people who ever lived were in subsistence agriculture, which needed constant labour to produce the food you needed to eat in order to keep yourself and your family alive.
Yes, the majority of people who ever lived, but for most of the time we’ve existed we didn’t need to do much labor at all. The reason it’s the most people who ever lived is because the agricultural revolution trapped us into having to grow more food to feed a growing population that could grow more food to feed a growing population that could grow more food.
I don’t see how you could see my original claim of
“Humans are laboring creatures”
Respond to it with
“Humans need to labor in order to make food to survive”
And still come from a place of disagreement.
Never did I claim “people work just to work”. We don’t see people spending every waking hour outside making mud pies. We don’t see people spending entire days moving 100-ton blocks from one side of town to the other just for the hell of it.
If people liked to work we wouldn’t invent labor-saving devices
If people didn’t like to work, we wouldn’t have began down the perpetual path of putting effort into meticulously engineering labor-saving devices.
If we liked to work we’d prefer to do everything by hand than use a something that saves our labor.
No one said that, wanting to do something on a daily basis is normal. But if I didn’t have to pay rent, for food, etc. I would certainly not be doing what I’m doing now on the daily, and if I did I wouldn’t be able to afford to live.
Nobody wanted to house you in the first place. That was the whole point of paying us. We are more expensive now. If you can’t afford us, tough shit.
Maybe this helps with the fallacy
The question is whether an individual’s right to be housed and a corporation’s right to have employees are the same, and what kind of society do we want to build.
Removed by mod
It’s the fault of ticker tock and gay teachers.
Removed by mod
Joined 1 day ago
