there’s still goofy magic sci-fi designs now, and there have always been more ‘realistic’ designs based on (to varying degrees) real scientific and engineering knowhow. the only way one could come to this conclusion would be by cherry-picking your examples. if you compare ‘the jetsons’ to ‘mass effect’, sure, it supports your conclusion, but on the other hand, contrasting ‘rick and morty’ against ‘2001: a space odyssey’ would give a rather different conclusion.
I finished reading Dragon’s Egg (1980) recently and at the back of the book was schematics, drawings, and layouts describing the various things in the novel.
There, indeed, have always been varying levels of “hardness” in sci-fi.
Yup. And in the past they didn’t have as much scientific knowledge as we do now. So past sci-fi has a lot of concepts that seemed legit back then, but later we found out things simply don’t work that way. And there’s also ideas of things that would work, but we found better solutions that are more economically feasible later on.
A shuttlecraft that’s basically a box with some cylinders strapped onto it made sense in the 1960s. Cylinders are like rockets, what we used for propulsion to get to space. Aerodynamics? Who cares?
But knowing what an actual space shuttle looks like makes people more likely to design something closer to that. And there’s a greater understanding of the importance of aerodynamics when entering an atmosphere by everyone so people are less likely to buy into a new design that doesn’t make these considerations unless there’s some nostalgia involved.
Exactly, what is believable space travel before the space race should be different to what’s believable space travel at the end of life of the international space station. Even beyond what the experts know, now we know more too. In the 60s it would make perfect sense for people to bring orienteering gear onto a new planet, but now it would be ridiculous to not have exploratory vessels have the ability to set up a temporary gps with satellite drones. GPS is an everyday thing that just makes sense to people today.
I just want to say, i loved Dragon’s Egg for this level of detail to the physics. I even did some quick calculations why you want 6 compensator masses not less to reduce the effect of tidal forces. Or the black holes inside the sun, at first i thougt, this is impossible. Then i read some more on it an noticed its well researched.
I really love The Expanse for that, but it also ruined basically every other sci-fi for me.
There’s a few inaccuracies in The Expanse too.
Yep. There’s that one episode I can’t watch because most of it is the Roci somehow just floating ~10 metres above the surface of Ganymede and how it took only an hour or two to transit all of the Jovian moons… was that another episode? I don’t know, I never watch them. ;_;
Nevertheless, the way their ships are designed so that the thrust vectors of the engines match with humans not falling to their deaths when a hallway becomes hole.
Yeah that maneuver would work… if you had a few years to do it. But it was a race against the clock kind of episode they were doing that in.
Also the idea of spinning asteroids (like Ceres) to make artificial gravity was a good idea at the time. But the general consensus now is that asteroids are more like balls of gravel so if you spin them up, they’d just fly apart.
But it’s a great show despite the nitpicks. The ship designs are awesome and needing to do a flip and burns and stuff like that is cool to see.
But i like reading about the engineering in hard sci-fi…
I usually love and prefer the goofy look of old SciFi, but seeing the brutalist, utilitarian aesthetics of the tech in the two newest Dune movies convinced me of that the new designs can be awesome when done right.
Which is funny because nothing about tech in Dune isn’t just Sci-Fi magic. It’s worse than Star Wars in that regard.
except dune actually acknowledges in the later books that it runs on magic. but hey, what doesn’t?
I don’t think the tech in Dune runs on magic, it’s just some of the abilities people like the Bene Gesserit have is basically magic. Even that’s kinda explained by thousands of years of breeding programs and crazy amounts of training, but sure it’s basically magic. But the tech is just tech. It’s just that their tech is weird because it’s illegal to use computers.
For example space folding is done by Navigators who used spice simply because they didn’t have the computers needed to do the complex calculations. Later the Ixians make devices that can do those same calculations without the need for mutant human-worms living in a vat of spice.
have you read the books? there is a passage where Duncan (it might’ve been miles teg, it’s been a second) acknowledges that no one in the dune universe actually knows how space folding works. they know what the equations are, but not how they actually function
They know that folding space works according to a model that’s supported by empirical evidence. That’s about as science as it gets.
If some deeper understanding of the metaphysical nature of the universe were required for FTL travel, that would be magic. But that’s not the case, they have an equation that works, and they can use it without even knowing why it works.
We built airplanes, broke the sound barrier and put people on the moon when our theories of aerodynamics couldn’t explain how a bumble bee could fly. Would you consider airplanes that were built without a complete understanding of aerodynamics to be magic?
That is eminently believable speaking as an engineer. Often the equations presage the understanding of why things work
The natural result of canon-obsessed nerds.
So not true man there were way more explosion diagrams and shit back then, this hasn’t changed it’s just different artists work differently
They didn’t think it’s just magic back then either. They thought those things would be possible in the future.
Different ways of working, we don’t need to organize everything around hierarchies
Someone never read Clark or Asimov. Some of the sci fi greats were absolutely physics nerds
Vanquish! The greatest game no one played!
I played it. I know how cool jetpack kneepads are!
sci-fantasy is the ultimate genre :3
deleted by creator
