@Liwott It is the same community and the same Friendica server in both cases? Are there any differences? Possibly one is a reply to a comment and the other one a reply to the starting post?
Can you tell me how to find the id of the create activity for these notes? Then i can check the server logs for errors.
By the way, i noticed that Friendica publicly lists all the users who liked or disliked a post. That is supposed to be private in Lemmy (only used to calculate the score).
I did four tests from four accounts I own, all from the same friendica instance (poliverso.org):
- OK from a personal account: https://lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/151329
- OK from a personal “sandbox” account: https://lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/151337
- OK from a “news” account: https://lemmy.ml/post/219638/comment/151338
4) NOK from an “organization” type account: https://poliverso.org/display/0477a01e-1462-4de8-65bd-587299275161
It seems clear to me therefore that the problem lies in the fact that Lemmy accepts messages from the first three types, but not from an organization page. I hazard a guess (but I’m not a technician): is it possible that the “organization” account type in friendica corresponds to a lemmy account type that is not compatible with the answers (perhaps it corresponds to the “community” lemmy account type)?
You are right, Lemmy only supports
Group,PersonandService(same as Person, but marked as bot). Does a FriendicaOrganizationwork in the same way as a Person?@nutomic @Informapirata It works exactly the same. We do support all available types. But with the exception of
Groupthey behave the same.
@heluecht @sexy_peach @Liwott Yes, all three of them (including the one that got through). One of those who didn’t was posted by a user on a different instance. I’m noticing now that the two comments in question have in common that they carry hashtags, maybe that plays a role?
@liwott @sexy_peach @Liwott Existing or nonexisting hashtags are no problem. But when you say that the one that didn’t went through had been from a difference instance, then possibly this is the reason.
Hashtags seem to be the problem, at least that’s what comes out from very simple tests I just ran :
This looks like pointless simple commenting, but the reason was very simple :
- tests 2, 3 and 6 were delivered tolemmy.mlinstantaneously
- test 1, 4 and 5 are still underway, seemingly because
- 1 contains a hashtag
- 4 contained one, and editing it out didn’t help
- 5 is a reply to 4Hashtag seems to be the culprit
@heluecht
cc : @dessalines @nutomic
Yes, these are accounts of the same friendica instance managed with the same privacy policies and which always respond to the first post lemmy
@Liwott I’m always macfranc. Now I try to answer from this personal sandbox account
@Liwott Can you read this message?
@Liwott I think I understand the problem. I am able to reply on lemmy with this personal account, but I cannot reply with my account @informapirata (which is an “organization” type friendica account), probably because on lemmy he can only write a personal account. Take away a curiosity, is your liwott@nerdica.net account an organization account (or maybe a sandbox account that works the same way)?
@Liwott I’m always macfranc. Now I try to reply from this news type account
