Currently, I am using Pinaud Clubman. It makes me feel fresh like a grandpa. My wife likes it apparently, initial impressions was that I liked my Lucky Tiger more… It seemed to smell better to me and made my skin feel great… They both are quality and the clubman has been growing on me quite a bit. What are your favorites? What do you use?
This link has a lot of information on the formula change. I believe the formula switch happened post 1990s Proctor and Gamble acquisition, probably before 2008 when the name was changed from “Original” to “Classic” in the U.S.