Turns out it’s a rare drop from the forbidden forest spiders. Another player gave me the great suggestion of just refreshing the task though, which I somehow did not realize we could do! So just thought I would share for anyone wondering.

Also just remembered one more favorite, when Umbridge is being dragged away by Centaurs.

“I’m sorry, Professor. But I must not tell lies.”

Just found this sub, so I have one to add!

“I think I can tell the wrong sort for myself, thanks.”