It’s interesting: Vision Pro is the first headset with so many features intended to reduce isolation – EyeSight, Breakthrough, AudioPods – but it seems to get this criticism much more than others. (It’s not just you: a lot of people feel this way, and Apple’s attempts to address the issue don’t invalidate the viewpoint.)

I wonder if it’s because Apple’s marketing is the closest most people have come to seeing a headset used in actual public spaces or in everyday life, as opposed to seeing it in the isolated rooms and workspaces of Meta, Microsoft, and Sony’s marketing. By drawing attention to their workarounds, Apple’s also drawing attention to the issue.

It reminds me of the increase in public concern about stalking after Apple released AirTags – the first keychain tracking device with features intended to combat stalking. Tile had been on the market for years at that point, but it was Apple that received the criticism because they’d drawn awareness to the issue.

I’m also old enough that I remember these same concerns being raised about personal stereos, and it was certainly true: earphones are still my favorite way to shut out my surrounding environment, especially somewhere noisy like a bus or train. But it’s not as though the older generation complaining about them were engaged in empathy-expanding conversation with each other: they’d bury themselves in books and newspapers in the surrounding seats.