Fellow Fediverse wanderers, I’ve got a bone to pick with our current Lemmy experience. 🌐
The “All” Feed Syndrome
Has anyone else noticed how painfully similar the “All” feed looks across different Lemmy instances? It’s like we’re browsing the same curated content, just with different window dressings. The posts, upvotes, and discussions feel completely uniform - a far cry from the diverse, decentralized dream I signed up for.
The Dream vs. Reality
What I imagined:
- A small film-focused instance with an “All” feed curated by passionate cinephiles
- A German instance showcasing content relevant to German users
- Niche communities with truly unique content bubbles
What we got:
- Homogenized content across instances
- US-centric discussions dominating global communities
- The illusion of decentralization without the benefits
My Wishlist: Local Votes Only
What I’m craving is a simple setting that would:
- Filter posts based ONLY on local instance votes
- Showcase truly instance-specific content
- Break the algorithmic echo chamber
- Highlight unique community perspectives
Imagine seeing genuinely different content on lemmy.world vs sh.itjust.works vs [your favorite instance]. Right now, it feels like we’re just shuffling the same deck of cards.
A Call to Developers
Is this technically feasible? Would love to hear from the community about:
- Potential implementation challenges
- Interest in such a feature
- Alternative solutions to content diversity
Who’s with me in wanting a more genuinely decentralized browsing experience? 🚀
#lemmy #fediverse #decentralization
Strongly disagree. This is just recreating what already exists, using a technology that’s actually not great for it. Each website’s connections should in some way resemble what that website is tailored to. And we don’t need a network of websites that are tailored to “looking exactly like every other website, because we couldn’t be arsed to pick a niche”.
Well, I strongly disagree right back.
Especially smaller instances regularly have reliability or federation issues, so it’s vital for me to be able to hop to an alt account and still get the same all feed.
That’s the whole point of the Fediverse, and Lemmy instances. Mastodon instances look like each other, to an extend.
And even here, https://lemmy.dbzer0.com/ and https://lemmy.world/ default themes look different.
If you want a truly different layout, there is https://fedia.io/m/floatingisfun
But that’s a unique case, because Mbin allows community-based themes