It’s going to dip again when third party apps are shut off. Personally I’m still browsing Reddit to check in on the drama on /r/ModCoord
Yeah exactly this. Most of the subs I used to be active in are still restricted or just meme subs now. I’m checking in to watch the drama until I can’t use RIF anymore, but it’s all lurking for me now and I just don’t have any interest in engaging there anymore.
just use teddit.net/r/ModCoord - privacy-respecting alternative.
dunno, but third party usage were never that high IIRC. that’s why them targeting third party apps is a weird decision
It’s not weird at all. The traffic is low so they don’t give a shit and by killing them third party apps they avoid questions from investors about loopholes in their ad feeding platform. Reddit wants to go public now so they have to be big boys, and we all know what it means under ripe capitalism. No mission, only revenue
by killing them third party apps they avoid questions from investors about loopholes in their ad feeding platform
No mission, only revenue… and smoke and mirrors? A bait-and-switch to fool investors?
Because if third-party app usage really is that low, and Reddit is losing money regardless, you’re describing putting a Band-aid on a hemorrhage and declaring the patient cured.Are investors really that stupid? Just another meaningless ritualistic sacrifice at the altar of investment capitalism? “Show them that you’re doing something. Just do something, make a splash, whatever it is, I don’t care. Act like you’re REALLY busy. Enough sucker investors won’t look into the numbers.” And how is this any different from incompetent russian generals invading Ukraine? They look to me like mirror images of each other.
Then again, there’s greed, the impulse for total control, biting off more than you can chew then not being able to back down because of pride and arrogance, emotional incompetence, and damn the consequences, both short and long term, the collateral damage. And here the Ukraine analogy is once again wafting across my mind.
EDIT: After all, so many of these corporate assholes - Walmart, Home Depot, Nestlé, and yes, Twitter and Reddit - they DO lean right wing.
don’t more people use third party apps than the official app?
Apollo has 25m downloads, I can’t imagine that the various Android 3rd party apps are any lower than that in total, if not individually.
Officially they make up a small amount of traffic, but amongst power users who both create and comment significantly is much more commonly done through 3rd party apps.
I went on Reddit yesterday for the first time since the strike, whilst trying to debug a code issue. Almost every post from years old questions had the replies deleted by the users. I think the real damage will be the deletion of content and the change in tone from redditors. Most useful discourse will be gone and it will turn into a place only for arguing, memes and shit posting. Advertisers aren’t going to want to pay to advertise on low quality content like that.
Punishing future searchers is what has me conflicted about wiping everything. I have an 11 year account. I have no idea how many times my troubleshooting was correct for various issues or howany times my anecdotal incidents could match for someone else.
xkcd: Wisdom of the Ancients
https://imgs.xkcd.com/comics/wisdom_of_the_ancients.png
Rollover: “All long threads should have a globally editable post stickied to the top saying” DEAR FUTURE USERS, here’s what we’ve learned so far"
Since I didn’t figure out image embedding, here’s the regular link https://xkcd.com/979/
i wont wipe my reddit account because i dont want to destroy the posts i made.
You can scrape them. Bots are slowly importing posts to Lemmy communities from their legacy sources
The Reddit board are profiting off you though, your knowledge in those searches has value and you see zero while.spez and co get millions. Try to get it off Reddit.
deleted by creator
It just feels dirty. The odds of someone coming across an old thread vs them posting + me seeing are very disproportionate. I’ve seen a lot of sites turn to shit and it hurts to actively contribute to that. I’m a tiny fraction of it, but part of it nonetheless. I feel like Roy Batty in his rainy monologue in Blade Runner as I reminisce among what I’ve seen. I’ve seen Facebook become the #1 social site and allow beautiful groups to flourish, only to collapse under it’s own weight and greed and become an unsearchable stream of consciousness. I’ve seen photobucket gain titan status among image hosting, only to allow greed to permanently destroy decade-old archives among forums. I was there when forums changed formats that would break 15 years worth of inter-thread link formats, shredding the web-like connections between dormant discussions. I remember the adorable, embarrassing exchanges posted to MySpace bulletin boards as an embedded video played over an audio stream with clashing text colors before that was eclipsed by the clean, mature format of Facebook. And now, we’re in another wave of Reddit degradation as so many users wipe their data in spite of the poor executive decisions. We thought the internet was forever, that anything posted was eternal. We feared sharing anything sensitive due to the viral nature of the web. But, as it turns out, it’s not so permanent. Those critical viral moments spread like fire on flash paper and were forgotten just as fast. Corporate greed and poor management has proven again and again this is all temporary. All of those moments, those posts, lost in time like tears in rain.
deleted by creator
Well host those comments on your own website and submit it to Google to be indexed?
It’s not realistic. I’m not THAT helpful. I just know the value I’ve found in ancient threads myself. I can’t really sift through my own shit posts in any meaningful way and I can’t bring the entire discussions with me.
That will just get you buried under the hordes of SEO garbage. People add “reddit” to their searches because regular search is useless.
There are forums that are still being run for the stuff I need or youtube. I’ve managed to avoid reddit search results for two weeks and used steam or dedicated forums for every thing else from tech stuff to cooking. I never used reddit for anything but doomscrolling so I’m familiar with other resources.
I truly feel most of the 3rd party app users were the more level headed folks in the userbse. For the most part we were users there since before reddit had an app when good discourse took place. We’re taking that discourse with us and I anticipate further deterioration of reddit. More akin to Facebook style toxicity and echo chambering. I’m sad to see it because overall that’s a net loss for humanity/the internet. But I like it here.
Welp they are getting way less traffic from me. All I do is occasionally log on and see which subs are creatively protesting now 😆
I totally believe this. Exactly zero of the 11K subscribers of the sub I mod have followed me over to the fediverse–despite a third of them ‘supporting’ the idea of keeping the sub dark.
Still deciding if I should just be an ‘absentee mod’ (not post anything personally, but keep things reasonably orderly) or let someone else mod it and move on. I just cant, in good conscience, ‘return to normal’.
Reddit doesn’t support you, your fellow users don’t support you. Do right by yourself and stop giving free effort for no benefit.
Do it wrong. Internal protest is the best protest.
Relax the rules to basic reddiquette and allow posting of anything. I think a few subs are doing that and you’ll get people posting stuff like Hong Kong awareness, reddit news, etc.
You could also start posting nsfw content which I think InterestingAsFuck were doing because it blocks Reddit ads and monetisation.
I’m more curious about how the numbers will look after they nix 3rd party apps. There’s bound to be a dip after June 30.
Are there a significant number of users using third party apps? Would be interesting to see.
I’ve seen an overview from a popular sub a while ago, as far as I remember a third were using 3rd party apps at least part of the time. Many people use multiple ways to view Reddit though, apps on mobile, old Reddit in a tab at work etc.
Yes, that was the precursor to all this; The API changes and it’s effect on 3rd party apps.
Last I saw they account for something around 10 000 0000 users. But that number is dwarfed by the official app.
Yes, but many of the “power users” (ie, not lurkers who downloaded the official app because its the "official app) are the ones making content which drives enagement who are using 3rd party apps, as well as the majority of mods AFAIK.
All we can do now is speculate until the price of API access pushes our 3rd party apps in July.
Are there a significant number of users using third party apps? Would be interesting to see.
I always said, redditors are good at complaining, but do nothing else.
r/workreform is one of the most popular subs, yet reddit’s userbase can’t even protest online properly.
Your work reform is never coming, plebbit. just saying.
Sadly, I think this is widely true about people in general. Actually commiting to change is so much harder than expressing dissatisfaction with your current state.
except this is not “I gotta threaten to quit my job if it doesn’t improve”, “stop eating meat”, or “switch to a bicycle instead of a car”.
This is a “I gotta open a different app and start lurking there daily and occasionally post”.
Switching to lemmy took me an hour. How difficult is this protest, really?
I mean, how much hope is there for humanity with that level of indifference/apathy.
*France enters the chat “The fuck we do”
Occupy Wall Street comes to mind.
The George Floyd protests eventually brought about justice to the killers, but so many protests never pan out unless extreme violence and complete revocation of the current system takes place, which has never happened in American protests due to the general populace’s sense of comfort.
Occupy Wall Street
Was that failure organic or due to sabotage from a modern COINTELPRO, though?
It smelled like a barn there when it was going on. No plan whatsoever to deal with hygiene. I talked to them a few times and listened. They couldn’t even set up a basic organization structure or even agree to decorum in voting like Robert’s Rules. Plus they couldn’t stay on message. I spoke to a person who identified themselves as a spokesperson who continued to say over and over again “I can’t speak for others about that”.
You don’t need to invent a plan by the CIA to destroy that. It is like every single idea of how to organize a protest was thrown out the window and replaced with well nothing.
COINTELPRO was an FBI thing (not CIA), but never mind that. Maybe the problem was that they were scared of such infiltration, and over-corrected by trying not to have any hierarchy at all.
Consumers are notoriously difficult to organize for boycotting and protests. There’s nothing that actually unites different Reddit users beyond using the same service, so solidarity is nil.
I’m not going back, but I was looking for the exit for a while anyway vOv
“I did something about it! I liked someone’s angry tweet!” Then they watched Netflix, distractedly fondling their purity and lovingly sniffing their fingers. bOtH pArTiEs ArEtHe SaMe LoL aMiRiTe
I’ve cut out Reddit, if lemmy dies my social media use dies with it.
I’ll be here contributing to the community as long as everyone else is.
I continued to look reddit for reasons, but honestly the feed is deteriorating fast, maybe traffic is back, people posting content, not so much, engagement? Even less, it’s like looking to a old mediocre Google News feed.
Fine with me, found a good substitution here after 11 years of reddit
Engagement is up because an algorithm optimized it.
The algorithm does not care if that engagement is negative or toxic.
Yeah, I at least personally used to be a bit of a power user and have just stopped posting/upvoting/downvoting altogether, and I’m not even a mod.
Just because people show up does not mean people are engaged.
deleted by creator
Yeah where is this data coming from?
deleted by creator
No way it’s legit
Once Apollo is inactive, so am I.
I’ve been here 50% or more. Won’t be hard, lol. Idiots
Maybe it’s the novelty here or something but I’m really enjoying Lemmy overall. Agreed switching over completely won’t be difficult in the slightest
There’s less comments, but also no low-effort jokes at the top for karma.
I actually forgot those were a thing in the week since I killed my reddit account! Every post getting bombed into oblivion with one-liners was crazy annoying.
This is 100% what I love about the switch. It’s not spammed with reposts and bots karma farming.
Ill admit its taking a hot minute to get setup on Lemmy, find communities and such. But Im enjoying it.
Yup, once boost is dead I’ll be over here on lemmy full time.
For me it’s Sync, which is thankfully working on a Lemmy app.
From what I have seen, traffic is down 9-10% now, which is quite significant.
https://www.similarweb.com/blog/insights/social-media-news/reddit-blackout/
Also the world has found out there are alternatives, so if mobile apps stop working or cost money by July, we may see a similar drop again.
What happens after that is hard to say. IMO reddit has steadily deteriorated compared to what it was 15 years ago. I miss the old reddit, what reddit is today I won’t miss.
Reddit will probably survive, and that may be for the best for Lemmy too. As long as Lemmy stays sustainable, I think we are better off without most of the people who choose to stay with reddit. Because those are likely to also be the people who don’t really care about values.
It depends what percentage of power users/content creators/OPs are in that 10%. Most online communities have a pretty lopsided compsition of posters vs. lurkers. If all posters move, the community will be eaten from the inside-out by repost bots.
I think the way reddit was going, quality content creators were already drowned out in many places.
We have a few bots here already making posts, I’m not sure how good or bad they are, but I’d prefer a site without bots. Where things are posted, because someone actually found it relevant here.
Reddit will probably survive, and that may be for the best for Lemmy too.
I never thought about that and that makes a lot of sense to keep the problematic users over there.
Let the sheep stay, while we enjoy some fresh air in the fediverse.
Returns to normal… minus me, HA TAKE THAT SPEZ!
Obviously if PC Mag says it it must be true. /S
I was an active member of reddit for over a decade. That ended during the blackout and I refuse to go back. I have blocked reddit at the router level to ensure they see no traffic from my network
I had 11 years there. I do miss the interface and pure volume of content (235 subs as of a week ago), but I’m enjoying the conversations here which is the part that meant the most to me. I hate to see it go, but the fact is their app is shit and I use mobile, so when RiF goes im out.
