Tried to make on new account on lemmy… It did work in the end (obviously). Good thing there is the audio version to read it for me. (sarcasm, I know it’s supposed to be for accessibility purposes. Still used it though)
I had the same difficulty with Lemmy’s captchas. Took multiple attempts before I figured out the right letters. The audio description helped a lot because it calls out which letters are capitalized. I’s and l’s and 1’s should be banned from those things.
Any letters that look like another should be exempt. I’m looking at you, C c W w U u O 0 o S s Z z X x V v
deleted by creator
this one, I think it was. At the very least in the audio description it said “uppercase A”.
Yeah I was just adding to the description that the audio helped a lot. It shouldn’t though, I think. Isn’t that supposed to be for people with some kind of sight disability? Otherwise why even have the graphical one.
It might not be long until we design the captchas so that the only ones who can get it right must be AI.
I think the CAPTCHAs have to keep getting harder and harder because the bots keep getting better and better.
>make captcha to train bots with human feedback
>bots become not only better, but more humanlike at solving captcha
No one could have possibly predicted this at all.
It is already a lost race though.
For instance, when humans were asked to solve distorted text CAPTCHAs, they were able to solve them in 9 to 15 seconds. That sounds great until you learn that they were only able to get the answer correctly 50-84% of the time.
On the other hand, bots taking the same texts were able to answer the same tests in less than a second, and they were able to do it more accurately—99.8% accurately, specifically.
https://www.pcmag.com/news/bots-better-at-solving-captchas-than-humans
google’s captcha basically doesn’t even use the actual puzzle anymore. That’s only used to train their AI. Its based mostly on how you interact with site.
welp
hmm yeah but at what point do we stop? If I already can’t solve it without using the audio description or refreshing multiple times, I think we need to think about another solution. Or just make it less hard, if “stopping the bots” is not the only reason.
They’ve already determined that bots are better at solving Captchas than we are.
More security theater is the obvious solution!
I can never read those damn things. Maybe I’m a robot and I just don’t know it yet.
